• Home
  • About PI
  • Sermon Resources
    • Biblical Resources
    • Theology
    • Apologetics
    • About Preaching
  • Sermons
    • Historical American Sermons
    • Patristic Sermons
      • Festal Sermons
        • Nativity of Theotokos
        • Holy Cross
        • Entrance of Theotokos
        • Christmas
        • Theophany
        • Meeting of Christ
        • Annunciation
        • Palm Sunday
        • Ascension
        • Pentecost
        • Transfiguration
        • Dormition of Theotokos
      • Lenten Sermons
        • Triumph of Orthodoxy
        • St. Gregory Palamas
        • Veneration of Cross
        • St. John Climacus
        • St. Mary of Egypt
      • Paschal Sermons
  • Webmaster Resources
  • Preachers Institute Store
  • Bible Challenges

PREACHERS INSTITUTE

You are here: Home / Author Index / Reardon, Patrick Fr. / Does Everyone Have Equal Access To Things Unseen?

August 30, 2015 By Fr. John A. Peck

Does Everyone Have Equal Access To Things Unseen?

by Fr. Patrick Henry Reardon

chosenIt is instructive to reflect on the apparent implausibility—indeed, the scandal—of the biblical claim to a favored position for a particular people within history. How is it possible that any people could be God’s chosen people? The claim represents an affront to both the Perennial Philosophy and the widespread religious assumptions of mankind. (I have, on occasion, spoken with Jews—the Chosen People themselves!—who were resistant to the idea.)

To deny that claim, however, on grounds a priori, is to deny the historical quality of the Christian faith—a thing some Christians seem prepared to do. But to deny that historical quality—or in any way to diminish it—is to forsake the very Gospel.

Although I have always believed that philosophy may be the servant of Sacred Theology, this will hardly be possible unless philosophy takes its directions from Theology, as any servant should, not vice-versa. An abiding problem of what I may call “the Scholastic Impulse” shows itself when the roles are reversed—those instances when Theology is not given a voice until philosophy has already set the agenda. I believe this reversal goes a long way to account for the weakening of a historical sense in Scholastic Theology (not, in my opinion, a completely Western problem).

Likewise, history is an area of humane studies very resistant to the laws of science and mathematics—the laws, that is to say, that govern all human beings in certain essential respects, regardless of their when and where in this world. To assert, as Christians do, that Revelation and Redemption enter human experience through contingent historical facts and events may seem to inhibit most men’s access to Revelation and Redemption. This is the reason the Christian claims were rejected by, for instance, the thinkers of the Enlightenment, who thought that man’s relationship to God (if God exists, which most of them accepted) must be kept quite separate from history.  

RELATED  Shopping For Jesus

Let me try to express the apparent implausibility of the Christian claim another way: Let us admit, as an experiment, that classical Greek philosophy was correct in regarding the pursuit of virtue as the proper path to a well-lived life, or (in recognizable Latin) man’s bene esse.

Now, contrast this classical assumption with the last line of a poem Holy Church prays every Saturday, when She declares of God,  

“He announces His word to Jacob, His claims and judgments to Israel. He did not treat every nation this way; nor did He disclose His judgments to them” (Psalm 147:9).

This is a pretty firm rejection, it seems to me, of that classical Greek hypothesis about everybody’s equal access to things unseen.

Christians declare that God’s claims and judgments—the stuff of Revelation and Redemption—are the substance of man’s true bene esse. Yet, God limited their disclosure to a specific stream of history: the Jews (including, of course, Jesus and the Apostles). In the fullness of time, God did disclose His historical claims and judgments to the Greeks, as well, but the Greeks were obliged to receive this Revelation as a gift from an improbable handful of Jews, who came wandering over from the Levant.

This is what I call the apparent implausibility—scandal, even—of the Christian assumption about history. Why, asks the Perennial Philosophy, should everybody have to depend on claims and judgments God revealed only through Jewish history? Surely we are permitted to ask,

“Are not the Abana, and the Pharphar, rivers of Damascus, better than all the waters of Israel?”

A proper response to this question should make the point that the Perennial Philosophy, in making this objection, is reacting from a simple and straightforward bias. It assumes, on the basis of nothing but a preference, that man discovers his capacity for transcendence—and, consequently, his capacity to receive a message from God-only through an abstraction from everything that is not God, history in particular, and a particular history especially. Although its adherents seem almost never to admit the fact, the Perennial Philosophy, in its flight from history, deliberately chooses timelessness, thereby manifesting what is only an epistemological bias, a closed mind and nothing more.

RELATED  The Mission of Bishops: To Preach The Gospel

 

 

 

Filed Under: Reardon, Patrick Fr., Sermon Resources, Theology Tagged With: chosen people, Fr. Patrick Henry Reardon, history, revelation

About Fr. John A. Peck

Director of the Preachers Institute, priest in the Orthodox Church in America, award-winning graphic designer and media consultant, and non-profit administrator.
Blog; Facebook;Twitter

Preachers Institute

Recent Posts

  • Is God a Fool?
  • It’s Time to Abuse the Devil
  • St. Mark of Ephesus and the Council of Florence
  • The Filioque in Brief
  • A Pagan Records the Slaughter of the Innocents by Herod
  • The Books Will Be Opened
  • The Apostle John and the First Letter of Clement to the Corinthians
  • Nothing Strikes Fear in the Person Whose Hope is in God
  • On the Plague
  • Marriage Perfection to Rival the Holiest of Monks
  • The Compilers of the Philokalia Answer the Opponents of Frequent Communion
  • The “Smoking Gun” of Non-Chalcedonian Christianity
  • Salvation of Christians Outside the Orthodox Church
  • On Moral Heresy
  • Septuagint Quotes in the New Testament

Preachers Institute Archives

Preachers Institute

The Online Orthodox Christian Homiletics Resource
Fr. John A. Peck, director
Phoenix, AZ

Find what you’re looking for

The Deep Dark Archives

Vocations in Orthodoxy

Good Guys Wear Blackwww.rolex-replica.me
rolex kopior

swiss replica watches store

replica rolex
watchessaleoutlet.com
best replica watch site 2021

Copyright © 2023 John A. Peck · Designed by John A. Peck